How has the media portrayed Stuttering
Hi Everyone! My name is Isaiah, and I am a second-year Post-Baccalaureate student studying to be an SLP. I wanted to ask how you have felt the media has historically perceived stuttering, and whether it is currently changing to what you would like to see?
![]()

Thank you for the question.
Historically, media has been cruel to showcase invisible disabilities as something to laugh at! Be it stuttering, Tourette’s, Nerodivergent conditions, etc.
Indian film industry had a blockbuster movie where one of the 4 main characters was unable to speak,so he would communicate by sounds and gestures, and he was the main laughing point of the whole movie, which had 4-5 sequels. The career of that actor really took off after that, and he is now known for that role only. It did not help the case of people who sutter, or people with speech variations AT ALL, more over it made us comic, something worth laughing at!
I was re-watching Harry Potter , first movie, last night with the kids (just a little before-bed ritual) and I realised that the character, professor Quirell had a stutter , or a speech variation and the whole characetr was defined by that – he was considered timid,shy and at-times stupid (which we know at the last that he was not), which indicated that people with speech variations are not intellingent(??) enough to NOT do stupid things! or are not considered generally harmful as they cannot be smart enought to harm (??) – I hope I am able to express what I am thinking.
Having said so, I believe media representation is now changing and we see people with disbilities taking up their space and owning up to their character, which is nice.
Thank you for this fascinating question, Isaiah!
Since I’m not much of a film fan or TV fan, I may not be the most informed respondent for this question. But I will do my best!
Traditionally, the depiction of people who stutter in films and TV has just been horrid, until about 16 years ago, when things started changing,
There were films like “A Fish Called Wanda”, where stuttering was basically included for increased laughs. There were the Porky Pig cartoons, which I and many others who stutter couldn’t stand – they ridiculed stuttering. “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest” had a stuttering character with special mental/emotional problems. There have been scenes in films implying that stuttering was some kind of behavorial deficiency that could be “fixed” with the right kind of attitude adjustment.
Stuttering was virtually never shown as a natural difference of speech that many happen to have. Stuttering characters were teased and humiliated, or were meant to increase laughs in a comedy, or the stuttering was depicted as a symptom of a mental/emotional disorder.
What started to change all this was the award-winning film “The King’s Speech” (2010). For the first time, a widely seen film had as its central cnaracter a non-fictional well-known and well-admired person who had a stuttering problem – and whose stuttering experiences were treated with sensitivity, realism, and compassion. Stuttering was not there for laughs; it was not there to show teasing or people making fun of the person; it was not there to imply that the person had some kind of mental/emotional disorder.
The stuttering was treated with respect and kindness, in a knowledgeable and understanding way, and as a disorder that the person just happened to have. it showed that national leaders, even in times of war and crisis, can stutter – it showed that people who stutter can hold very highly esteemed positions, and be a leader and role model for millions.
I’m aware that there have been many other positive depictions of stuttering in films and TV in subsequent years, though I’m not personally familiar with them. And I’m also aware that stuttering for laughs, stuttering for teasing, and stuttering as a symptom of a mental/emotional disorder, are disappearing from the media. And that pleases me a great deal.
Maybe other respondents to this question will give more recent examples of this welcome change of perspective.
In any case, I wish you well in your coming career.
– Paul
There are a few TV series out now, with stuttering characters or real people. And the portrayals (when in a drama series) is proper. A Norwegian “Emergency Room” series by The Norwegian State Broadcasting company (Norsk Rikskringkasting) has a stuttering character. He was worried that his stuttering would be detrimental to the show, but the producer liked it, since it was natural (IDK if the character was meant to stutter).
The attitudes towards stuttering on film is changing. It has taken a long time, but the time when stuttering was something to be laughed at, is mostly gone.
Although the myth that if something Big Happens, the stuttering magically disappears. Either because you got chewed out by The Boss and found the guts to talk back to him (like in “The Cowboy[s?]”, with John Wayne) or in the Norwegian movie “Beatles” (based on the novel by Lars Saabye Christensen). In the movie, we follow four young boys in their “formative” years, and the various Beatles albums influence their thoughts. Anyhow, in the movie, one of the boys has a stutter. Towards the end, his stutter is suddenly gone! And why? He found looove.
We all know that’s not how it works. In the movie “Pan’s labyrinth”, set during the Civil War in Spain, there is a terrible interrogation scene where a partisan has been tortured, and he has a stutter (portrayed realistically). Towards the end of the scene, the interrogator tells him if he can count to three without a stutter he can go free. It goes badly… But the point is realistic: If you have a stutter, it won’t disappear whether your’e angry, in loooove or very afraid.
Of course, if you’re angry, you may be more focused and stutter less then and there, but you won’t be cured.
Hi Isaiah
What is funny to some can be hurtful to others. I personally love the movie The King’s Speech, as it shows his struggle and his victories. I recognize his frustration, the reactions from others and even some of the exercises. And when I hear the words “Because I have a voice!” I still get all teary. But some people don’t like it, because it claims he was “cured”, which he wasn’t. He simply learned some techniques how to give speeches in a more smooth way.
In A Fish Called Wanda, the guy who stutters was “cured” when he crushed his bully. In Harry Potter the teacher who stuttered, was a villian who faked his stutter. In many other movies we’re sterotyped is nervous, liars, villians, etc.
I myself heard about a famous Swedish comic who’d play the role of a PWS in a comedy serie. I contacted him and told him that there’s a thin line between funny and hurtful. He told me not to worry. When the series started, the PWS was spitting, he was nervous, confused, he was bullied, he was attacked and assaulted. The only positive thing was that he stood up to his bullies. There was one scene where someone put a footbal horn in his mouth, he was bound to a chair, and when the bully pressed the horn he said “This will stop you from stuttering, you woodpecker”. When I heard a boy in school had a shower head pushed inside his mouth hearing the same words, I was done and I contacted the largest newspapers in the country, who interviewed me and printed it. Un the follow-up, there was no PWS. (They simply made a fool of other disabilities…) The comedian contacted me telling me I ruined his career. I told him he did. (He’s still an amazing, famous and loved comedian, even by me. He just ruined his own reputation by making fun of people with disabilities.)
A group of PWS worked on a project watching every movie where a PWS was portrayed, and it showed it wasn’t all that bad. Have a look at https://www.stamily.org/post/project-stuttering-in-movies
Keep them talking
Anita