Assessment Process – Broken or Quality?
Hi everyone! My name is Gracie!
For PWS,
What is something you wish SLP’s would do during the assessment process looking back on your personal experience? Unless you felt like it was conducted perfectly, what did that look like?
Professional Panel,
How can SLP’s adapt their stuttering assessment to respect cultural differences when the client and/or their parents culture (depending on age) may be prohibiting them from getting the proper treatment needed?
![]()

Thank you for asking these important questions, Gracie!
I’m on the PWS panel, so I’ll answer the question posed to people who stutter. (I also have a graduate education in speech-language pathology, but I’m not a practicing SLP.)
I believe strongly that speech-language pathologists should take the time to do a careful assessment of a client before beginning speech/language therapy, and I think this is particularly important with a client who stutters.
I severely stutter. In my own extensive experiences as a client of therapy programs, very seldom was there any kind of assessment session beforehand. Too often, clinics and clinicians have a “one-size-fits-all” approach to stuttering therapy, which in my humble opinion is the wrong approach to take.
People who stutter vary greatly in what types of stuttering therapy benefit them the most. For some, it’s a fluency shaping approach; for others, it could be a stuttering modification approach, combined with reduction of avoidance; for many others a psychologically based program, of developing self-acceptance and self-confidence in everyday life, would be the most effective treatment method. For still others, a combination of some of these approaches could be optimally effective.
At the outset of a therapy program, a decision needs to be made about which approach to try first. To help determine this, it would be crucial to interview the client about his or her previous experiences (if any) with stuttering therapies. Were there particular approaches in which the client made the most gains – either in improving fluency, reducing disfluency, or developing a better life perspective of self-acceptance or self-confidence, as a person who happens to have a speech difference? It may help to explain different possible approaches, and ask the client which of these approaches sounds the most suitable for him or her at this time.
The clinician can also listen to the client’s speech to get an idea of the severity level; and also, from discussion, get a sense of how deeply stuttering is affecting the client’s life. These two could be entirely separate issues. For example, a client could have a severe level of stuttering, but it may not he inhibiting him or her much in their daily life activities. Or a client could have a very mild level of stuttering, but strong fears of stuttering in everyday life. In covert stuttering, there may be hardly any sign of disfluency at all, but still much avoidance of situations, or avoidances of particular words or sounds.
There is also the factor that a client’s speech in an assessment session may be significantly different from how the client speaks in most situations. It has been noted in the literature that often people who stutter, for some reason, speak more fluently when being evaluated, than in most of their situations. Or conceivably, the reverse could be true. The question needs to be asked if the client regards their speech during the assessment to be typical for them, more fluent than is typical for them, or more disfluent than is typical for them.
It would be best to limit assessment to one session, or a part of one session. People who stutter who come for therapeutic help would prefer not to wait through an extensive assessment process, before beginning to receive that help.
As mentioned above, I seldom received any assessments from clinicians when beginning a program. The clinicians simply presumed they knew what approach to stuttering therapy would be best. In too many cases, they used the same approach for all their clients who stuttered. (I knew this, because they informed me of that fact. “This is what we do to treat stuttering. Are you ready to begin our program?”)
Given the wide variations in stuttering – in levels of severity, in how much stuttering may be affecting one’s life, in how much the client may be avoiding (situations, words, sounds), in how much help the client may have received from different types of therapies in the past – imposing a “one-size-fits-all” approach for all stuttering clients just ignores therapeutic reality and individual differences.
I really wish that many of my speech clinicians took the time and effort to do a meaningful assessment before beginning therapy. That may be a large part of the reason why 80% of my therapeutic experiences were not helpful at all.
I estimate that I saw about 35 different clinicians over a stretch of about 35 years (late 1950’s to mid-1990’s, between the ages of 4 and 40). Of those I only count 7 who significantly helped me to any degree.
I hope this has all been helpful to you.
Good luck in your future caeeer!
– Paul
Hi Gracie! Thank you for bringing up such an important question!
I’m Michèle Ayoub, a person who stutters, part of the PWS panel, and actively involved in the stuttering community.
Looking back at my own experience, I wish SLPs had focused less on how much I stuttered and more on how stuttering was affecting my life.
I think an assessment should go beyond counting stuttered words or measuring fluency. Ask us how we feel about our stuttering, what situations we avoid, what we struggle with, and most importantly, what WE want to get out of therapy.
Someone who barely stutters might be struggling emotionally much more than someone who stutters openly and frequently. You can’t always measure the impact of stuttering by what you hear.
And I wish more SLPs would remember that the goal isn’t always to speak fluently. Sometimes, it’s simply to feel comfortable being ourselves, stutter and all 🤍
Hi Gracie
When I was young, stuttering was taboo. Nobody talked about it. Not at home, not at school. No one told me there were others. When I was in my late teens my school wrote a letter to my parents (which I found out many years later) that I should see an SLP. This didn’t go well (private story), but a few years later I tried another one. This didn’t go well either and I lost all trust in SLPs. I even other tried other therapists, f ex healing, hypnosis, etc. Long story short, they were all focused on my breathing and fluency. I can breathe. I play the saxophone. Stuttering? Wrong. the only goal was fluency. If their methods didn’t “work”, I was to blame. I was lazy. I “didn’t want to be cured”.
Later on in life I found a support group where we practiced public speaking. THIS became one of my keys to freedom. I could speak. Just not fluently. I also found other fantastic, dedicated SLPs who were no longer focused on fluency, but on making clients talk freely again. I also found Mindfulness and NLP. More keys. And I found the stuttering community. The biggest key of all.
Unfortunately, there are still SLPs who’s goal is fluency and less stuttering syllables. Fluency? Is it the SLPs who wants it? Parents? Teachers? Employers? If it’s something others want, it’s doomed to fail. Even worse, it can lead to silence, covert stuttering, fear, shame, low self-esteem, or even worse… Also, often parents are adviced to be their child’s therapist, which makes me sad. PWS tend to always be on our guard, wondering what other people might think of our stutter. Parents, home, should be a safe zone where any way of talking is allowed. The first goal should be to find a way where a PWS can say what, when and how he wants to.
So start with listening. Ask questions and listen, before you even think of starting therapy. As we all bring different things to the table. Background, culture, religion, family, age, gender, and our many different experiences. This goes for clients of all ages. You may find out that not all clients come for total fluency. Some want answers, some want a family member to know more, some want some tools to speak with less tension, some want to practice job interviews, some are there because the parents want the child to be fluent while the child just wants to speak freely, some want help with self-esteem, etc etc. When you get a picture of the client and what they want (at that moment, as it can change along the way, and if that’s reachable of course), you can start offering a smörgåsbord. This can be all from speech training to refer to relaxation, mindfulness, NLP, speaking circles, theatre, art, presentation techniques, yoga, swimming, singing, and maybe even a combination.
Also show the way to the stuttering community. This group is not instead of, but can be a great addition to therapy. People who walked the walk and literally talked the talk. They can help with exercises, help to speak in school or at the workplace, support outside the therapy room, etc. They often have gatherings, camps and some even have virtual meetups, even international ones, with meeting friends and simply playing games together.
With acceptance being the safety net, you can start the journey of practice, challenging yourself, and go for your dreams. Acceptance doesn’t mean you’re done. It means you catch your breath and get ready for the next step, whatever that step may be.
And help me to find my true self, and my self-worth. Show me what I’m good at, and that stuttering is not bad and fluency good, but that stuttering just IS. And that it’s not up to me to make my listener happy, but maybe instead up to the listener to simply… listen. Help me to see there’s more in life than fluency. And that I’m good enough either way. But to also help me to find tools that fit me and my stutter, ways to explain to others what stuttering is, ways to meet bullies and other people not getting it. Ways to speak to my teachers. And show me the way to stutter camps, where I can be me, speak freely, without any therapy, and where my parents can come and speak with adult PWS. As the more we understand, the more we feel good enough, the more we lose the shame. So be a friend.
Most of these advices can work with both adults and children. With children, however, make sure you listen to the child and not just to the parents, as they can have different goals, and the child might tell you what s/he thinks others want to hear. So have them both together and separately. Also, group meetings are good, to show they are not alone, and do exercises together, the same for parents.
Lastly: stop counting stuttered syllables. Just because someone stutters less, doesn’t mean things are going great. It can also mean the iceberg is getting under the surface, and thus way harder to notice, and to treat. So, listen not only with your ears, but also with your gut, to what’s not been said.
Sounds tricky? I promise you that, as soon as you gain your client’s trust, you’ll have an existing road ahead, walking and working together, sharing ups and downs, and enjoy the progress, whatever this word includes for that very client.
Keep them talking
Anita
Hi Gracie,
I’m writing from the Professionals Panel. This is an important question! It’s so essential that our work as SLPs, right away from when we begin speaking with the person/family gathering intake information, is tailored toward the individual/family. By leading with curiosity and helping to guide someone to explore and share about their own experience of communication to whatever extent they are comfortable at the outset, we can do our best to meet the client where they are with our assessment and treatment. For example, there are several formal measures of the cognitive, affective, and behavioral aspects of stuttering; I usually use a combination of interview and a formal measure, but may opt for interview alone to gain this information if a particular formal questionnaire doesn’t seem like it would be a good fit for any reason including cultural identity.
-Carrie