↓
 

Comments

Harmful Tactics in Speech Therapy — 5 Comments

  1. Hi, and thank you for this unusual, but important question!

    I have to change the question somewhat, in order to fit my viewpoint and my own experiences.
    During my life, I estimate I have seen about 35 different therapists for my severe stuttering (yes, you read that correctly, about 35 different therapists!). In these therapies, I encountered a wide variety of approaches.
    There were only 7 therapists that I found significantly helpful to me. All the rest weren’t of any help whatsoever. Some were fluency shaping programs; others emphasized the psychological side of stuttering (including reduction of avoidances). In my most successful programs, I enjoyed temporary periods of consistent fluency, lasting for weeks or months. But always there was a relapse sooner or later.

    I wouldn’t regard any particular therapy program that I had as being “harmful”. Many were not helpful in the least, but they didn’t cause harm – the worst programs were a waste of time and money, but they didn’t cause me harm; my speech didn’t worsen in those programs, but just didn’t improve.

    In knowing hundreds of other people who stutter, from attendance at many national/international stuttering conferences and conventions, my belief is that almost every therapy program helps some people a great deal, others to a limited extent, and others not at all. Yes, some also find that a therapy program not suitable for them can make their speech temporarily worse; but typically, once they stop using such a program, their speech returns to its pre-therapy level. So I believe it would be rare for a therapy program to permanently worsen a client’s speech, or cause permanent psychological damage.

    My therapies at various clinics all occurred between the ages of 4 and 40. Beginning in my late 40’s, I shifted my philosophy entirely, and gave up my long quest to transform myself into a fluent speaker. I started to accept myself with calmness and confidence as a person who happens to stutter, a person with a speech difference. And I found that this brought greater pleasure to my life, and took a huge pressure off my shoulders.

    But to get back to your question: If I were to rephrase the question to fit my own experiences, it would ask about the worst therapy program I ever went through – one that not only didn’t help, but also in retrospect was an absolutely complete waste of time and money.

    At a university where I was a grad student of music, I tried an expensive program run by the Psychology Department. It was early 1977; I was 22 years old, and it was during a period when my stuttering was much more severe than it is now. I was having very long blocks on almost every single word. (The payments for this program were deceptively called “voluntary donations”, which effectively ruled out any kind of health insurance coverage. Luckily I had a well-to-do grandfather who covered the costs.) In tbis program, I learned a simple fluent pattern of speech, based on breathing and phrasing.

    The clinicians were of the even more simplistic opinion that once someone learned their fluency pattern inside the clinic, it could then be applied in all other situations. And if it wasn’t so applied, the reason must be that the client CHOSE to stutter rather than using the pattern, due to some deep-seated benefit the person was receiving from stuttering.

    The therapy sounded to me like nonsense from the outset. But the clinic claimed a 98% cure rate, and I was really desperate for speech help. With a 98% chance of a complete cure, and my great difficulties of speech at the time, I jumped at the opportunity to try it out.

    I had immense trouble applying their speech pattern in the outside world, and I certainly knew I was NOT choosing to stutter, nor was I receiving any benefit from stuttering. The clinic spent hours with me trying to figure out what was the alleged deep- seated reason for my “wanting” to stutter in so many situations. Why was I so (allegedly) tied to my stuttering? Why was I so adverse to using their technique? What benefit was I receiving that made me wish to stutter so severely, and refuse to use their technique? We explored these questions in depth, even though – deep inside – I completely rejected their concepts. In reality, I WANTED to be fluent – I wanted to use their fluency technique. But I just could not do it, no matter how hard I tried.
    A few months later, they called me in for a follow-up. I asked point blank if I was among the 2% who had “failed” their program. Yes, they told me. I was (allegedly) among the 2% who had “failed”. (In retrospect, I do not believe their 98% claim.)
    To the best of my knowledge, this clinic no longer exists. The psychology professor who had devised and run the program has passed away. I have read or heard no more about the program in the years since. Looking back at this experience, I am glad this clinic no longer exists.
    Did the clinic help some people? Yes – I have met others who went through the program; and though they are not cured, tney report that the program was helpful to them. To me, it wasn’t helpful at all – not in the least. And that damn program was incredibly expensive!

    Anyways, that’s my most negative story from my many therapy experiences.
    Luckily, it did not cause harm. My speech after the program was exactly as it was before the program. It was a waste of time, money, and effort.

    I wish you the best of luck in your coming career!
    – Paul

    • Hello Paul!

      Thank you for your in-depth and insightful response, and most of all thank you for sharing your story! I am saddened by the clinicians claim that you chose to stutter due to personal benefit, especially when you were trying to comply with their program. I’m sorry for the money and time that program cost you! I appreciate your commentary on wasted effort rather than harm from unhelpful therapy, and I will bring your story with me as I continue through my speech therapy schooling. Thank you again!

      – Chloe

  2. Fluency shaping therapy was particularly harmful to me.

    In my perception, I changed one way of speaking with which I was uncomfortable with another way which made me even more self-conscious and uncomfortable.

    The effort to produce “shaped” speech was exhausting, and often I could not focus on both my message and the effortful production of shaped speech.

    And when I stuttered, the sense of failure and shame were much worse than before that “therapy”.

    The stuttering-repressing fluency-shaping therapy is outdated and harmful. There are much better, modern approaches that are stuttering-affirmative, such as the CARE model and Avoidance Reduction Therapy. When those therapies are supported by mindfulness training, they are even more effective.

    Hanan

    • Hello Hanan!

      Thank you for sharing your story. I have heard a similar experience with fluency shaping therapy echoed throughout the PWS commentary in the ISAD conference this year. I agree that stuttering-affirmative programs provide a much more positive and holistic therapy experience for individuals who stutter. I appreciate your thoughts, thank you again!

  3. Hi cnaylor

    When I was young, stuttering was taboo. Nobody talked about it. Not at home, not at school. No one told me there were others. When I was in my late teens my school wrote a letter to my parents (which I found out many years later) that I should see an SLP. This didn’t go well (private story), but a few years later I tried another one. This didn’t go well either and I lost all trust in SLPs. I even other tried other therapists, f ex healing, hypnosis, etc. Long story short, they were all focused on my breathing and fluency. I can breath. I play the saxophone. Stuttering? Wrong. the only goal was fluency. If their methods didn’t “work”, I was to blame. I was lazy. I “didn’t want to be cured”.

    Later on in life I found a support group where we practiced public speaking. THIS became one of my keys to freedom. I could speak. Just not fluently. I also found other fantastic, dedicated SLPs who were no longer focused on fluency, but on making clients talk freely again. I also found Mindfulness and NLP. More keys. And I found the stuttering community. The biggest key of all.

    Unfortunately, there are still SLPs who’s goal is fluency and less stuttering syllables. Fluency? Is it the SLPs who wants it? Parents? Teachers? Employers? If it’s something others want, it’s doomed to fail. Even worse, it can lead to silence, covert stuttering, fear, shame, low self-esteem, or even worse… Also, often parents are adviced to be their child’s therapist, which makes me sad. PWS tend to always be on our guard, wondering what other people might think of our stutter. Parents, home, should be a safe zone where any way of talking is allowed. The first goal should be to find a way where a PWS can say what, when and how he wants to.

    So start with listening. Ask questions and listen, before you even think of starting therapy. As we all bring different things to the table. Background, culture, religion, family, age, gender, and our many different experiences. This goes for clients of all ages. You may find out that not all clients come for total fluency. Some want answers, some want a family member to know more, some want some tools to speak with less tension, some want to practice job interviews, some are there because the parents want the child to be fluent while the child just wants to speak freely, some want help with self-esteem, etc etc. When you get a picture of the client and what they want (at that moment, as it can change along the way, and if that’s reachable of course), you can start offering a smörgåsbord. This can be all from speech training to refer to relaxation, mindfulness, NLP, speaking circles, theatre, art, presentation techniques, yoga, swimming, singing, and maybe even a combination.

    Also show the way to the stuttering community. This group is not instead of, but can be a great addition to therapy. People who walked the walk and literally talked the talk. They can help with exercises, help to speak in school or at the workplace, support outside the therapy room, etc. They often have gatherings, camps and some even have virtual meetups, even international ones, with meeting friends and simply playing games together.

    With acceptance being the safety net, you can start the journey of practice, challenging yourself, and go for your dreams. Acceptance doesn’t mean you’re done. It means you catch your breath and get ready for the next step, whatever that step may be.

    And help me to find my true self, and my self-worth. Show me what I’m good at, and that stuttering is not bad and fluency good, but that stuttering just IS. And that it’s not up to me to make my listener happy, but maybe instead up to the listener to simply… listen. Help me to see there’s more in life than fluency. And that I’m good enough either way. But to also help me to find tools that fit me and my stutter, ways to explain to others what stuttering is, ways to meet bullies and other people not getting it. Ways to speak to my teachers. And show me the way to stutter camps, where I can be me, speak freely, without any therapy, and where my parents can come and speak with adult PWS. As the more we understand, the more we feel good enough, the more we lose the shame. So be a friend.

    Most of these advices can work with both adults and children. With children, however, make sure you listen to the child and not just to the parents, as they can have different goals, and the child might tell you what s/he thinks others want to hear. So have them both together and separately. Also, group meetings are good, to show they are not alone, and do exercises together, the same for parents.

    Lastly: stop counting stuttered syllables. Just because someone stutters less, doesn’t mean things are going great. It can also mean the iceberg is getting under the surface, and thus way harder to notice, and to treat. So, listen not only with your ears, but also with your gut, to what’s not been said.

    Sounds tricky? I promise you that, as soon as you gain your client’s trust, you’ll have an existing road ahead, walking and working together, sharing ups and downs, and enjoy the progress, whatever this word includes for that very client.

    Keep them talking

    Anita

↑