↓
 

Comments

Feeling Supported — 3 Comments

  1. Thank you, Emma, for this most interesting question!

    In my own case, I have a multitude of answers, since I estimate I’ve seen about 35 different therapists in my lifetime for stuttering – with a great variety of therapeutic approaches.
    Of the many clinicians I have seen for speech, I count seven who were significantly helpful to me, and three of those were VERY helpful.
    I will concentrate here on the therapists who were significantly helpful to me.

    I began stuttering at about age 3, and started to see speech therapists at about age 4. By that time, my stuttering was severe.
    I had many speech therapists during my childhood, but none were able to help, or even seemed to understand anything about severe stuttering.
    When I was in high school, I had my first experience with a clinical program that actually was helpful. I learned traditional techniques such as pullouts, reducing secondary symptoms, and reducing avoidances. The lengths and frequency of my blocking, for the first time in my life, started to improve.

    As an undergraduate, I had a number of helpful therapies. One speech pathologist (they weren’t called SLP’s then), who I saw for three years – who also stuttered himself – gave me some very important advice that I followed the best I could, even though it wasn’t easy. After he got me to admit, with some reluctance on my part, that I had no close friends to speak of, he told me that I MUST get out there and meet people, REGARDLESS of how severe my stuttering happened to be. (And at that time, my stuttering was considerably more severe than now.) So I did. On the college campus where I was then a student (I was about 20 years old), I made it a point to meet as many of my fellow students as I could. I still stuttered very severely, but my social life improved immensely, and I discovered a very important fact that I hadn’t realized before – that most people just don’t care how fluent you happen to be; they’re much more interested in your CONTENT, not in how you say it.

    My next therapy seemed almost miraculous. When I was a college senior (in the mid-1970’s), I was involved in an experimental program based on following commands in speaking fluently for increasing lengths of speech units. Eventually I became able to speak fluently for extended periods of time. This didn’t involve techniques, simply a certain mindset. I remember vividly talking fluently on the phone to a friend for an hour, a totally new experience for me – my first fluency ever, outside a speech clinic. (I was then age 21.) I was so absolutely amazed! I had little understanding of WHY this was happening. (My clinicians simply told me that I was “controlling” my speech. But I knew that I wasn’t.) Even today, it’s hard to explain. Eventually a third of my situations became fluent, and another third had reduced disfluency. I told the clinicians that these felt like mysterious “fluency feelings” – which they dismissed as nonsense. But this didn’t last. After about a half-year, it all fell apart. The clinicians wondered why I wasn’t “controlling” my speech any more. But I knew I never had been. This was just something mysterious, with nothing solid behind it.

    About a year later, I tried airflow therapy at a clinic in New York City. At first I was able to use the technique inside the clinic, but not outside the clinic. But after the therapy week, for months I diligently practiced the technique daily. And my speech gradually improved – until I was speaking fluently in about a third of my situations, with the airflow technique. I was enjoying my speech progress.
    But eventually my progress fell apart (within a half-year), and my severe stuttering was back in all situations.

    Seven years later (at the age of 30) I entered a program in which I found the most success. This was the Precision Fluency Shaping Program, developed by the Hollins Communications Research Institute, Roanoke, Virginia. (Both the program and institute no longer exist.) In that program I learned specific techniques involving breathing, gentle onsets, and stretched sounds.
    At first, as in other programs, I could just use the techniques inside the clinic.
    But after the three-week program, I practiced very diligently for an hour or more a day. Within three months, I was fluent EVERYWHERE – something I had never before experienced in my life. Indeed I felt that I would never stutter again – I felt “cured”!
    But, alas, I wasn’t. My initial fluency did last for quite a few months. When I practiced intensively and daily, I was consistently fluent. But when I slacked off in practice, my fluency declined, and stuttering returned. Since I couldn’t always practice for an hour a day, I couldn’t maintain the fluency in the long term.

    For years, I had numerous intensive week-long refreshers, trying to bring back the old magic. And indeed I succeeded at this many times following refreshers, enjoying consistent fluency for periods of weeks, and sometimes months. But it was never permanent, and always fell apart eventually.
    For about 15 years, that was the pattern – a fluent period following a refresher, then a disfluent period, then a fluent period following a refresher, then a disfluent period. Over and over again. I got tired of this.

    About 25 years ago, I changed my speech philosophy entirely. I decided that fluency was no longer a life goal of mine. I started accepting myself as a person who just happens to stutter. And if I happen to be disfluent, well so what? Life happiness and satisfaction do not depend on consistent fluency of speech. That is a lesson that took me many decades to absorb.
    Once I got rid of my former obsession to be as fluent as I possibly could be at all times, my life happiness increased. Once I got rid of the overwhelming desire to become a fluent person, I began to see life in a new way. I could accept ME, just as I was – and as I am today – a person who happens to have a stuttering difference. That’s all. Enormous pressure was lifted from my shoulders, and I now could enjoy life to the fullest. However I speak, that’s how I speak. And if I’m not the most fluent person in the world, well so what?
    And come to think of it, this new approach – which was total self-therapy – was my best therapy of all!

    I hope this rather lengthy account has been helpful to you.
    Best luck in your future career!
    – Paul

  2. Hi Emma, thank you for your question.

    When I was you, stuttering was taboo. Nobody talked about it. Not at home, not at school. Noone told me there were others. When I was in my late teens my school wrote a letter to my parents (which I found out many years later) that I should see an SLP. This didn’t go well (private story), but a few years later I tried another one. This didn’t go well either and I lost all trust in SLPs. I even other tried other therapists, f ex healing, hypnosis, etc. Long story short, they were all focused on my breathing and fluency. I can breath. I play the saxophone. Stuttering? Wrong. the only goal was fluency. If their methods didn’t “work”, I was to blame. I was lazy. I didn’t want to be “cured”.

    Later on in life I found a support group where we practiced public speaking. THIS became one of my keys to freedom. I could speak. Just not fluently. I also found other fantastic, dedicated SLPs who were no longer focussed on fluency, but on making clients talk freely again. I also found Mindfulness and NLP. More keys. And I found the stuttering community. The biggest key of all.

    Unfortunately there are still SLPs who’s goal is fluency and less stuttering syllables. Fluency? Is it the SLPs who wants it? Parents? teachers? Employers? If it’s something others want, it’s doomed to fail. Even worse, it can lead to silence, covert stuttering, fear, shame, low self-esteem, or even worse…

    So start with listening. Ask questions and listen, before you even think of starting therapy. As we all bring different things to the table. Background, culture, religion, family, age, gender, and our many different experiences. This goes for clients of all ages. You may find out that not all clients come for total fluency. Some want answers, some want a family member to know more, some want some tools to speak with less tension, some want to practice job interviews, some are there because the parents want the child to be fluent while the child just wants to speak freely, some want help with self-esteem, etc etc. When you get a picture of the client and what they want (at that moment, as it can change along the way, and if that’s reachable of course), you can start offering a smörgåsbord. This can be all from speech training to refer to relaxation, mindfulness, NLP, speaking circles, theatre, art, presentation techniques, yoga, swimming, singing, and maybe even a combination.

    Also show the way to the stuttering community. This group is not instead of, but can be a great addition to therapy. People who walked the walk and literally talked the talk. They can help with exercises, help to speak in school or at the workplace, support outside the therapy room, etc. They often have gatherings, camps and some even have virtual meetups, even international ones, with meeting friends and simply playing games together.

    With acceptance being the safety net, you can start the journey of practice, challenging yourself, and go for your dreams. Acceptance doesn’t mean you’re done. It means you catch your breath and get ready for the next step, whatever that step may be.

    And help me to find my true self, and my self-worth. Show me what I’m good at, and that stuttering is not bad and fluency good, but that stuttering just IS. And that it’s not up to me to make my listener happy, but maybe instead up to the listener to simply… listen. Help me to see there’s more in life then fluency. And that I’m good enough either way. But to also help me to find tools that fit me and my stutter, ways to explain to others what stuttering is, ways to meet bullies and other people not getting it. Ways to speak to my teachers. And show me the way to stutter camps, where I can be me, speak freely, without any therapy, and where my parents can come and speak with adult PWS. As the more we understand, the more we feel good enough, the more we lose the shame. So be a friend.

    Most of these advices can work with both adults and children. With children however, make sure you listen to the child and not just to the parents, as they can have different goals, and the child might tell you what s/he thinks others want to hear. So have them both together and seperately. Also group meetings are good, to show they are not alone, and do exercises together, the same for parents.

    Lastly: stop the counting syllables. Just because someone stutters less, doesn’t mean things are going great. It can also mean the iceberg is getting under the surface, and thus way harder to notice, and to treat. So listen not only with your ears, but also with your gut, to what’s not been said.

    Sounds tricky? I promise you that, as soon as you gain your client’s trust, you’ll have an exiting road ahead, walking and working together, sharing ups and downs, and enjoy the progress, whatever this word includes for that very client.

    Keep them talking

    Anita

  3. Hi Emma! Thank you for such a thoughtful question!

    I actually have a beautiful experience to share about a speech therapist I had in my early teenage years. Looking back, I think she helped shape part of who I am today, even though I only worked with her for about a year before she moved out of the country.

    She was the first person who encouraged me to speak openly about my stuttering. I remember her encouraging me to give a presentation about stuttering to my entire class. For the first time, I stood in front of my classmates and talked about something I had always felt I needed to hide.

    She also invited me to speak to her university students studying speech-language pathology. Imagine being a young teenager, standing in front of future SLPs, explaining what it feels like to be a person who stutters!

    She didn’t just work on my speech. She gave me a voice and a stage to use it. And I think that’s something that has stayed with me all these years.

    But here’s the interesting part. After those experiences, I went back to not talking about my stuttering for many years. It was almost as if those presentations were projects I had completed, rather than the beginning of a conversation I felt comfortable continuing.

    And this brings me to something I wish more SLPs understood: confidence on the outside doesn’t always reflect what’s happening on the inside.

    I wish someone had looked beyond the confidence I was trying to show and helped me understand the emotional and psychological impact stuttering was having on my life. I wish I had been introduced to psychological support and behavioral approaches much earlier. I believe that could have saved me years of avoidance, hiding, fear, and habits I developed to protect myself from uncomfortable situations.

    Sometimes, we become so good at appearing confident that people don’t realize how much we’re struggling internally.

    Today, I speak openly about stuttering, organize community events, and advocate for people who stutter. And I can see how that early experience planted a seed that eventually grew into what I do today.

    So my advice to future SLPs is to encourage your clients to use their voices, create opportunities for them to speak, and celebrate their courage. But don’t stop there. Keep checking in with what’s happening beneath the surface, even when someone appears confident and successful.

    Because helping someone find their voice is powerful, but helping them feel comfortable and safe using it in everyday life can be life changing

↑