↓
 

Comments

Beyond Fluency: Understanding the Everyday Impact of Stuttering — 2 Comments

  1. Hi Kinsley and thank you for your interesting question. Let me start by this: don’t learn about fluency. Learn about making PWS talk. Giving them tools to talk with less effort, and with more confidence. Stuttering treatment is so much more than fluency, while, when the focus is on attaining fluency, the risk is that the stuttering iceberg goes underneath the surface, and PWS will turn into covert, hiding.

    I can only speak from myself, as we all come in different shapes. It became clear my stutter started to affect my life when I started hiding my stutter. I was a confident, social and outgoing child, but became more and more silent, as the people around me reacted negatively towards my stutter, and my fear and shame started to take over my love for speaking. I started avoiding people and speaking situations, stopped raising my hand at school, stopped with social activities, and kept myself to my room. The more I heard from my teachers it was no use for me to study as I wouldn’t get a job anyway, and kids laughing at me, I believed them, and didn’t see a future.

    I wanted to end my life (I wrote about that in revious ISAD online conferences, which you can still read). But when meeting the right people, people who say me behind my stutter, and other people who stutter, I realised I wasn’t my stutter. I was so much more. And thanks to them I started to see my skills and my personality, I started to challenge myself, putting myself into tough situations, realizing that my stutter didn’t stop me, as long as I felt confident about myself and my skills, which projected onto my listener. The more I believed in myself, as a person, wife, mother, employee, etc, the more people saw all these parts of me, accepted and respected me. So when I decided to face my demons and go back to school, they asked me to become a teacher. Who wouldn’t have thought, me who hated school, was now a teacher, and even taught teachers!

    So yes, stuttering is tough, but so are PWS. Help your client to focus on what they’re good at, both when it comes to skills, passion and personality. Help them expand their comfort zones. Help the people around them to understand what stuttering is and what it is not. Help them to find the stuttering community. Children camps, youth camps, adult events, as feeling you’re not alone and seeing people who stutter and still follow their dreams is so uplifting!

    My husband says I’m not the woman he married (in a positive way). I’m the one making the phone calls, do the errands, join community and organisational boards, speak up at political meetings and make the complaints. 😉 I still stutter, but no longer with shame and fear, and through saying what, when and where I want to say it, my stutter has decreased. Win-win. 🙂

    Keep them talking!

    Anita

  2. Hi Kinsley! Thank you for such an important question!

    I think one of the biggest challenges is that we don’t always know how to express what we’re going through. And sometimes, we don’t even realize how much stuttering is affecting our lives until years later.

    Looking back at my own experience, I was often the confident, outgoing person. I wanted to be seen as strong, capable, and independent. But behind that confidence, I was making so many decisions based on my fear of stuttering without even realizing it.

    And here’s something I think future SLPs should pay attention to: sometimes the clients who seem to be doing perfectly fine are the ones who have become really good at hiding their struggles.

    We can also become people-pleasers. We want to give the right answers, show progress, make our therapists happy, and avoid disappointing anyone. So when someone asks, “How are things going?” we might automatically say, “Good!” even when there’s so much more happening beneath the surface.

    Instead of only asking how their speech has been, I would encourage SLPs to ask questions about everyday decisions.

    “Is there something you wanted to do this week but decided not to?”

    “Have you ever changed what you wanted to say because you were afraid of stuttering?”

    “If stuttering wasn’t something you worried about, would you be making the same choices?”

    And give them time to reflect. Sometimes we need someone to ask the right question before we can recognize a pattern ourselves.

    I would also really encourage journaling and helping clients make it a habit. I believe writing can be such a powerful way to process feelings and emotions, especially the ones we don’t immediately recognize or acknowledge. Sometimes our minds try to push uncomfortable experiences aside as a way of protecting us from having to feel that discomfort again.

    Journaling can help bring those feelings back into our awareness, recognize patterns in our behavior, and understand why certain situations affect us the way they do. And sometimes, it’s easier to write something down than to say it out loud, especially when we’re not yet ready to share it with someone else.

    I also think it’s important not to expect someone to open up immediately. Trust takes time, especially when we’ve spent years protecting ourselves from judgment.

    And remember, avoidance doesn’t always look like silence. Sometimes it looks like choosing a different career, avoiding a relationship, changing a word, laughing something off, or convincing ourselves we weren’t interested in an opportunity anyway.

    So don’t just look at what your client is doing. Get curious about what they might be missing out on, and help them discover that for themselves, without judgment.

    Because sometimes the biggest impact of stuttering isn’t in the moments when we speak. It’s in all the moments when we decide not to.

    Best,
    Michèle

↑